Homemade Coffee Creamer is really easy to do yourself! Here’s dozen flavors you can make from one base recipe! Back in , I posted a recipe for Homemade French Vanilla Coffee Creamer..Transform your everyday coffee into something extraordinary with our delicious non dairy creamers..Transform your everyday coffee into something extraordinary. Vew all of our delicious non dairy creamers..Coffee Mate’s Original flavor is a cl.ic creamer that’s been in grocery aisles for ages. It’s held up over time, offering just calories and less than a gram of sugar per serving. It’s a more processed option than some of the others on this list, costing it some of the ranking..